If you care about your putter, you should care just as much about the cover that protects it. A good blade putter headcover needs to combine soft padding, a secure closure, and materials that can handle cart straps, rain, and travel without breaking down. This selection features handcrafted accessories from Ace of Clubs' collection, evaluated on material quality, craftsmanship, and style. Every headcover here is built in the USA and geared toward golfers who want their putter cover to look as good as their stroke feels. You will find classic full-grain leather, exotic alligator options, and baseball-glove leather designs, all available with deep customization. If you want to explore even more options, check the main headcovers collection.
Quick Picks
- Editor's Choice: WHITE LEATHER CUSTOM PUTTER HEADCOVER – Clean, tournament-ready look with maximum customization for logos, size, and interior color.
- Best Value: Baseball Glove Genuine Leather Golf Putter Headcover – Classic feel and premium protection at a lower price point.
- Premium Choice: ONYX ALLIGATOR CUSTOM PUTTER HEADCOVER – Exotic alligator leather for golfers who want true luxury on the greens.
- Best for Everyday Golf: Onyx Black Genuine Leather Golf Putter Headcover – Simple, durable full-grain leather that can live in and out of a cart all season.
- Best for Gifts: Brown Genuine Leather Custom Golf Putter Headcover – Easy to personalize and versatile enough to match almost any bag setup.
- Most Customizable: MIDNIGHT ALLIGATOR CUSTOM PUTTER HEADCOVER – Exotic leather with full control over size, logo, and interior details.
Product Comparison
| Product | Material | Price | Best For | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| WHITE LEATHER CUSTOM PUTTER HEADCOVER – Editor's Choice ⭐ | Full-grain leather | $160 | Clean, modern custom blade cover | 9.6/10 |
| ONYX ALLIGATOR CUSTOM PUTTER HEADCOVER | Full-grain alligator leather | $160 | Luxury, exotic look for blades | 9.4/10 |
| MIDNIGHT ALLIGATOR CUSTOM PUTTER HEADCOVER | Full-grain alligator leather | $160 | Deep customization with exotic leather | 9.3/10 |
| TOBACCO LEATHER CUSTOM PUTTER HEADCOVER | Full-grain leather | $160 | Vintage-inspired everyday gamer | 9.1/10 |
| Brown Genuine Leather Custom Golf Putter Headcover | Full-grain / genuine leather | $160 | Traditional brown leather look | 9.0/10 |
| Navy Genuine Leather Custom Golf Putter Headcover | Full-grain leather | $160 | Modern navy styling and logos | 9.0/10 |
| Baseball Glove Genuine Leather Golf Putter Headcover | Full-grain baseball-glove leather | $125 | Soft, broken-in feel at great value | 9.0/10 |
| Onyx Black Genuine Leather Golf Putter Headcover | Full-grain leather | $125 | Simple, durable black gamer | 8.9/10 |
| ONYX LEATHER CUSTOM PUTTER HEADCOVER | Full-grain leather | $160 | Custom black blade cover with logos | 9.1/10 |
1. WHITE LEATHER CUSTOM PUTTER HEADCOVER – Editor's Choice ⭐
Best for: Tournament-ready, clean blade putter headcover with full personalization
Price: $160
Material: Full-grain leather with soft fur interior
Category: Putter Headcover
Shop Now: View Product
Why It's Our Top Pick
This cover hits the sweet spot for most golfers who want a blade putter headcover that looks sharp on the first tee and still feels special years later. The full-grain white leather has a premium hand, but the real magic is the customization. You choose blade size, interior color, and whether you want your logo, initials, or a tournament mark. The soft fur lining and magnetic closure keep your putter finish safe while making it easy to take on and off with one hand. It balances material quality, craftsmanship, customization, and price better than anything else in the range, which is why it earns the top spot.
Strengths
- Full-grain leather exterior offers long-term durability and a premium look.
- Soft fur interior protects the putter face and topline from chatter and scratching.
- Magnetic closure is secure yet easy to use, even when riding in a cart.
- Extensive customization: size, interior color, logo, and personalization with live preview.
- White color pairs well with most modern bags and stands out on the green.
Considerations
- White leather will show dirt faster, so you need to be willing to wipe it down.
- Made-to-order customization means you should allow time before a big event.
- Premium pricing compared with basic putter covers, though justified by build and options.
Who This Is For
Choose this if you want a blade putter headcover that feels like part of your tournament kit, not an afterthought. It suits golfers who like a clean, modern aesthetic and who want their logo or initials front and center. If you are tough on gear, ride in carts, or travel with your putter, the full-grain leather and magnetic closure will hold up well. If you prefer darker colors that hide wear, look at the Onyx or Tobacco options instead.
Rating: 9.6/10
Bottom Line: A standout blade putter cover that blends classic white leather with true custom flexibility. Ideal if you want your putter to look as serious as your scoring.
2. ONYX ALLIGATOR CUSTOM PUTTER HEADCOVER
Best for: Golfers who want an exotic, luxury blade putter headcover without sacrificing protection
Price: $160
Material: Full-grain alligator leather with soft fur interior
Category: Putter Headcover
Shop Now: View Product
Why We Recommend It
If you like the structure and function of the white custom cover but want something more distinctive, the Onyx Alligator version steps things up. You still get a soft fur interior, magnetic closure, and custom sizing, but the full-grain alligator leather adds texture and depth you simply do not get with standard hides. It is a strong pick for players who already invest in premium belts or cash covers and want the same level of detail around their putter.
Strengths
- Full-grain alligator leather provides a truly exotic, upscale aesthetic.
- Magnetic closure holds firmly during cart rides and walking rounds.
- Custom size and interior color options help dial in the fit for your specific blade.
- Logo and personalization options allow tournament, club, or corporate branding.
- Black finish hides marks better than lighter leathers, practical for everyday use.
Considerations
- Exotic material may feel like overkill if you swap putters frequently.
- Dark textured leather makes small engraved details more subtle; good or bad depending on taste.
- Same price as premium full-grain options, but value is tied to how much you appreciate exotic hides.
Who This Is For
This is ideal if your putter is not just a tool but a centerpiece of your bag. It pairs perfectly with alligator or exotic belts from Ace of Clubs and works well if you favor mostly black or dark-colored setups. If you prefer understated smooth leather, the Onyx Leather Custom or Tobacco custom covers may be more your speed. For a slightly softer price and feel, the Baseball Glove headcover is another good alternative.
Rating: 9.4/10
Bottom Line: A luxury blade putter headcover with real alligator leather and full custom options. Best for golfers who appreciate exotic materials and plan to keep their putter for a long time.
3. MIDNIGHT ALLIGATOR CUSTOM PUTTER HEADCOVER
Best for: Maximum customization in an exotic, almost stealth-style blade putter cover
Price: $160
Material: Full-grain alligator leather with soft fur interior
Category: Putter Headcover
Shop Now: View Product
Why We Recommend It
The Midnight Alligator Custom sits between the White Custom and Onyx Alligator in terms of style. It uses rich textured full-grain leather in a deep black tone but leans heavily into the custom side. You get size selection, interior color, logo, and monogram options, plus a live design preview. If you are trying to match a team, club, or company brand color on the interior, this is one of the most flexible blade putter headcovers in the lineup.
Strengths
- Premium full-grain alligator leather with a rich, subtle texture.
- Soft fur interior and magnetic closure for excellent on-course protection.
- Live design preview reduces guesswork on logos and personalization.
- Custom sizes available to fit modern blades or slightly wider profiles.
- Midnight color plays well with almost any bag and belt combination.
Considerations
- Exotic leather demands basic care to keep the texture looking its best.
- Not as visually loud as some alligator patterns; some golfers may want more contrast.
- Customization lead time makes it less suited for last-minute events or gifts.
Who This Is For
Pick Midnight Alligator if you want an exotic blade putter headcover that still reads as classic and understated from a distance. It works especially well for lower-handicap players and pros who want branding on the putter cover but not something too flashy in photos. If you want more color pop, the White Custom or Navy Custom are better fits. For a more approachable, broken-in feel, the Baseball Glove cover is a smart alternative.
Rating: 9.3/10
Bottom Line: A highly customizable, stealthy alligator blade headcover. Ideal if you want exotic material, plenty of logo options, and a look that will age gracefully.
4. TOBACCO LEATHER CUSTOM PUTTER HEADCOVER
Best for: Golfers who want a vintage-inspired blade putter headcover that will develop a patina
Price: $160
Material: Full-grain leather with soft fur interior
Category: Putter Headcover
Shop Now: View Product
Why We Recommend It
The Tobacco Leather Custom putter headcover is for players who love the look of a well-worn leather bag or glove. Full-grain leather in a warm tobacco tone will darken and pick up character over time, so it looks better the more you use it. Under the hood you still get Ace of Clubs' soft fur interior, magnetic closure, and customizeable size, logos, and interior color. Think of it as a classic blade putter cover that is built to tell a story over seasons.
Strengths
- Full-grain leather ages beautifully, developing a unique patina.
- Custom logo and personalization options make it a great member-guest or club gift.
- Magnetic closure keeps the putter secure without the hassle of Velcro.
- Interior color selection lets you add a bit of contrast or stay understated.
- Tobacco color pairs nicely with brown belts and classic leather bags.
Considerations
- If you prefer a pristine, uniform look, patina and wear marks may not be your style.
- Brown tones may not match very modern, neon or bright bag setups.
- Same pricing as exotic options, but focused more on long-term character than flash.
Who This Is For
If you are the type of golfer who keeps gear for years and enjoys seeing it age, this tobacco blade putter headcover will hit the mark. It suits walking golfers, classic bag setups, and anyone who already gravitates toward brown or cognac belts. If you prefer a clean, bright look, consider the White Custom. For pure value with that “already broken-in” feel, the Baseball Glove headcover is also worth a look.
Rating: 9.1/10
Bottom Line: A warm, vintage-inspired custom blade putter cover that is designed to age with you. Great for traditionalists and leather purists.
5. Brown Genuine Leather Custom Golf Putter Headcover
Best for: Versatile brown blade putter headcover that works with almost any setup
Price: $160
Material: Genuine / full-grain leather with soft fur interior
Category: Putter Headcover
Shop Now: View Product
Why We Recommend It
This Brown Genuine Leather Custom headcover is a workhorse choice for blade putter players who still want something special. It brings the same feature set as the white version, with custom size, logo, and interior options, but in a slightly more forgiving brown tone. The leather is robust enough for everyday league play, but still refined enough for tournament bags and corporate logo programs.
Strengths
- Classic brown leather look that pairs with a wide range of belts and bags.
- Soft fur interior and magnetic closure for confident protection.
- Live preview for logos and personalization simplifies custom orders.
- Good balance of style and practicality for everyday use.
- Ideal color choice for gifts when you are unsure of the recipient’s exact style.
Considerations
- Less visually striking than alligator or bright white options.
- Brown shade may vary slightly as each piece of leather is unique.
- Same price as alligator customs, but with a more traditional material.
Who This Is For
Choose this if you want a safe, stylish option that is unlikely to clash with any golfer’s kit. It is especially good for corporate, team, or club gift programs where you need something everyone will be happy to use. If you know the player loves exotic leathers, the Onyx or Midnight Alligator might be a better fit. For budget-conscious buyers, the Baseball Glove cover delivers a similar vibe at a lower price.
Rating: 9.0/10
Bottom Line: A versatile, easy-to-like brown custom blade headcover with full personalization. A smart default choice when you want quality without overthinking the color.
6. Navy Genuine Leather Custom Golf Putter Headcover
Best for: Golfers wanting a modern navy blade putter headcover that ties into team or club colors
Price: $160
Material: Full-grain leather with soft fur interior
Category: Putter Headcover
Shop Now: View Product
Why We Recommend It
Navy is quietly one of the easiest colors to live with on the course. This Navy Genuine Leather Custom blade putter headcover brings all the same custom tools as the other leather options but with a color that works with most OEM head colors and bags. It is particularly strong if your club or school colors involve navy, white, or gold, since logos can really pop against the dark background.
Strengths
- Modern navy full-grain leather pairs well with many OEM head finishes.
- Custom logo and personalization perfect for teams, schools, or member events.
- Soft fur interior and magnetic closure match the protection of the top picks.
- Navy hides scuffs and dirt better than white while still looking sharp.
- Live design preview helps dial in thread and layout choices.
Considerations
- Navy leather will still show dust and light debris more than pure black.
- Less traditional than brown or tobacco if you like a classic vintage look.
- Pricing reflects full customization, so overkill if you do not want logos or names.
Who This Is For
This is a great fit if your bag, staff bag, or team kit leans navy or royal blue. It looks particularly sharp paired with Ace of Clubs navy belts or scorecard holders from the scorecard holder collection. If you prefer minimalist black, the Onyx custom options might suit you better. If cost is a bigger factor, look at the standard Onyx Black Putter Headcover without full customization.
Rating: 9.0/10
Bottom Line: A sharp, modern navy blade cover with full custom capabilities. Ideal if you want your putter cover to match team or club colors without going too loud.
7. Baseball Glove Genuine Leather Golf Putter Headcover
Best for: Golfers who want a softer, broken-in feel and strong value on a blade putter headcover
Price: $125
Material: Full-grain baseball-glove leather with soft fur interior
Category: Putter Headcover
Shop Now: View Product
Why We Recommend It
This is one of the most approachable blade putter headcovers in the Ace of Clubs lineup. Crafted from the same style of full-grain leather used in quality baseball gloves, it feels familiar and soft right out of the box. You still get a soft fur interior and magnetic closure, but at a lower price than the fully custom alligator and calfskin options. It is easy to understand why many golfers use this as their everyday gamer.
Strengths
- Baseball-glove leather offers a comfortable, broken-in feel quickly.
- Price point is friendlier while still delivering handmade USA construction.
- Soft fur interior and magnetic closure protect the putter during play and travel.
- Rich, traditional look that appeals to a wide range of golfers.
- Laser engraving and embroidery available for subtle personalization.
Considerations
- Less customization around size and interior color than the full custom series.
- Leather is more casual, which may not match very modern, all-black setups as cleanly.
- If you want a highly specific logo layout or color match, the custom series is better.
Who This Is For
Choose this if you want a blade putter headcover that feels comfortable and familiar from the first round. It is an especially good value pick for everyday play, league nights, and as a gift to baseball fans who golf. If you know exactly what logo and interior color you want, step up to the fully custom leather or alligator models. For a more minimalist black alternative, consider the Onyx Black Genuine Leather Putter Headcover.
Rating: 9.0/10
Bottom Line: A soft, durable blade cover with a nostalgic feel and smart pricing. Great as an everyday gamer or gift that will see a lot of real use.
8. Onyx Black Genuine Leather Golf Putter Headcover
Best for: Simple, durable everyday blade putter cover with premium leather and no custom wait
Price: $125
Material: Full-grain leather with soft fur interior
Category: Putter Headcover
Shop Now: View Product
Why We Recommend It
If you want the protection and feel of Ace of Clubs leather without needing a custom logo or complex spec sheet, this Onyx Black Putter Headcover is a very straightforward choice. Full-grain leather on the outside, soft fur inside, and a magnetic closure give you the same on-course confidence as the higher-priced customs. The all-black look is timeless and blends into just about any bag or belt combination.
Strengths
- Premium full-grain leather construction at a more approachable price.
- Soft fur interior and magnetic closure give reliable, quiet protection.
- Onyx black color is low-maintenance and hides marks and dirt well.
- Handmade in the USA for consistent build quality.
- No need to make design decisions if you prefer to keep it simple.
Considerations
- No built-in customization; logos and personalization require separate custom models.
- Standard sizing may not be as tailored as true made-to-order options.
- All-black look is subtle; if you want visible branding, another model is better.
Who This Is For
Pick this blade putter headcover if you want something you can order and start using quickly with confidence. It fits the golfer who values quality materials and construction but does not need a logo or monogram. It also works well as a backup or travel cover so you can keep a more customized piece pristine. For full customization in a similar color, look to the Onyx Leather Custom Putter Headcover.
Rating: 8.9/10
Bottom Line: A straightforward, high-quality black blade putter cover that just works. Ideal if you want premium protection without the extra decisions or cost of full custom work.
9. ONYX LEATHER CUSTOM PUTTER HEADCOVER
Best for: Golfers wanting a fully custom black blade putter headcover in smooth full-grain leather
Price: $160
Material: Full-grain leather with soft fur interior
Category: Putter Headcover
Shop Now: View Product
Why We Recommend It
The Onyx Leather Custom Putter Headcover fills a nice niche if you like the versatility of black but still want full personalization. It gives you the same full-grain exterior, soft interior, and magnetic closure as the other custom covers, but in a smoother leather rather than an alligator texture. If you work with corporate, club, or event logos that need to be crisp and legible, black leather with contrast stitching and thread is a very clean canvas.
Strengths
- Full custom sizing, logo, and interior color options, all on a classic black base.
- Soft fur interior and magnetic closure offer tournament-level protection.
- Black leather makes full-color logos and embroidery stand out clearly.
- Handmade in the USA with a rich, textured full-grain exterior.
- Excellent match to Onyx belts, cash bags, or scorecard holders for a coordinated kit.
Considerations
- All-black design offers less visual flair than exotic leathers.
- Lead time for custom production makes it less ideal for last-minute gifts.
- Price premium over the standard Onyx Putter Headcover is justified mainly by personalization.
Who This Is For
This is ideal if you already know you want a black blade putter cover, but also want a logo, initials, or event mark that will photograph cleanly. It pairs nicely with black or dark-colored bags and with the belt collection if you like a fully coordinated look. If customization is not important, the standard Onyx Putter Headcover will save some money. If you want texture and exotic appeal, one of the alligator customs is a better match.
Rating: 9.1/10
Bottom Line: A fully customizable black blade putter headcover that gives logos and stitching room to shine. Ideal for players and programs who want a clean, consistent visual identity.
Buying Guide
1. Consider Your Style
Before you focus on specs, think about how you want your blade putter headcover to look in your bag and on the green. Do you lean modern and clean, or classic and vintage? White or navy customs feel fresh and stand out on the putting surface. Tobacco and brown leather read more traditional and pair well with classic stand bags. Exotic alligator options sit at the luxury end of the spectrum. Matching your cover to your belts, cash covers, or scorecard holder helps pull everything together.
2. Understand the Materials
Most Ace of Clubs blade putter headcovers use full-grain leather, which is the most durable part of the hide. It can be smooth Italian calfskin, classic full-grain, or exotic alligator. Full-grain leather tends to break in and develop patina, while alligator maintains a more structured, textured look over time. Baseball-glove leather is softer and feels broken-in quickly. All are a big upgrade over synthetic putter covers that crack and peel under cart straps and weather.
3. Customization Options
One of the biggest advantages of staying within the Ace of Clubs range is the depth of customization. On the custom models you can choose size to match your exact blade or compact mallet, interior color, and how you want your logo or initials to appear. Laser engraving gives a clean, sharp look, while embroidery introduces color and dimension. For club programs, you can coordinate putter headcovers with belts or other pieces from the headcovers collection to keep your branding consistent.
4. Investment Perspective
A well-made blade putter headcover is an investment in your most-used club. You pull your putter on almost every hole, and cheaper Velcro-based covers tend to fail right when you start to trust them. Full-grain or alligator leather, a soft interior, and magnetic closure will extend the life of your putter finish and help keep the shaft and grip from chattering in transit. If you already invest in quality putters, spending a bit more on a cover that will last years is a smart move.
5. Care & Maintenance
Leather blade putter headcovers do not require complicated care, but a little attention goes a long way. Wipe off grass, sand, and moisture after the round, especially on lighter colors like white or bone. Avoid leaving your cover in standing water in the cart or on wet turf. Every so often, a small amount of quality leather cleaner or conditioner will keep full-grain and alligator hides supple. Store your putter with the cover on in your bag or locker to avoid unnecessary dings, and rotate between covers if you own more than one.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best blade putter headcover for beginners?
Beginners are usually best served by something durable, simple, and forgiving. The Baseball Glove Genuine Leather Golf Putter Headcover is a strong starting point. It provides full-grain leather protection, a soft interior, and a magnetic closure without the extra cost of deep customization. You still get a premium piece that feels great but do not need to worry about matching specific logos or colors yet.
How much should I spend on a blade putter headcover?
In this range, expect to spend around $125 for premium full-grain leather designs and about $160 for fully custom or exotic material options. If you already own a quality putter, that investment is reasonable given how often you use the club. The key is choosing a headcover that will hold up for years, not just a season, so you are not replacing cheaper covers as Velcro wears out or synthetic materials crack.
Italian calfskin vs exotic alligator – which is better?
Italian calfskin and full-grain leather are excellent all-around choices: durable, comfortable to handle, and easier to care for. Exotic alligator brings a more rigid structure and unique texture that many golfers love for the luxury feel. Performance-wise, both protect your putter well when paired with soft interiors and magnetic closures. The choice comes down to whether you prefer understated refinement or a more distinctive, exotic presentation in your bag.
What customization options are available and how long do they take?
On most custom blade putter headcovers you can choose size, interior color, and how your logo or initials are applied via laser engraving or embroidery. Many products offer a live preview so you can confirm the look before ordering. Production timelines vary, but you should budget several weeks for made-to-order work, especially if you are coordinating multiple pieces for an event, team, or corporate program.
How do I care for a leather blade putter headcover?
After rounds, wipe off any grass, sand, or moisture with a soft cloth. Avoid soaking the leather or leaving it in standing water. For full-grain and alligator leather, using a small amount of quality leather cleaner or conditioner a few times per season helps maintain flexibility and color. Store the cover in a cool, dry place and keep it on the putter when traveling to prevent dings and chatter in the bag.
Are premium putter headcovers really worth the investment?
If you play frequently or travel with your clubs, a premium blade putter headcover is usually worth it. High-quality leather and a soft interior protect your putter’s finish better than thin synthetic covers, especially with a secure magnetic closure. You also get the benefit of a more professional look in your bag. When you factor in how often you use a putter, the cost spread over several seasons is easy to justify.
Can I match my putter headcover to other accessories?
Yes. One of the strengths of working within a single brand like Ace of Clubs is the ability to coordinate pieces. You can match your blade putter headcover to belts, cash covers, and items from the headcovers collection using the same leather colors or exotic materials. That consistency makes your kit look intentional rather than pieced together.
Our Methodology
These recommendations come from hands-on experience with leather golf accessories and an understanding of how putter covers are treated during regular play, travel, and storage. Ace of Clubs offers a deep range of handcrafted blade and mallet putter headcovers, so each option here was evaluated on real-world usability, not just looks. All products are from Ace of Clubs, a USA-based brand specializing in handmade leather golf accessories since 2012. Founded by former PGA Professional Dan Pusilo, each product is evaluated on material quality, craftsmanship, and value.
Evaluation Criteria:
- Material Quality (30%)
- Craftsmanship (25%)
- Style & Design (20%)
- Customization (15%)
- Value (10%)
Final Verdict
If you want a clean, tournament-ready blade putter headcover with full personalization, the White Leather Custom Putter Headcover is the safest all-around choice. Golfers who prefer a more traditional or vintage look will be happy with Tobacco or Brown custom leather, while those chasing luxury should look hard at the Onyx or Midnight Alligator customs. For everyday value or gifts, the Baseball Glove and Onyx Black headcovers are easy winners. Explore Ace of Clubs' complete collection of handcrafted leather accessories, made in the USA with full customization available, starting with the main headcovers collection.
Last updated: December 2025
